When it comes to pushing physical limits, athletes are constantly trying to find new ways to enhance performance and break through barriers. Whether it's running a marathon, completing an Ironman, or competing in CrossFit, athletes must push their bodies to the edge of exhaustion. But what happens when they try to bypass the natural safety mechanisms built into their bodies? In a recent discussion, Sean Hiller and Kyle Ruth of Training Think Tank explored this idea, comparing the experiences of athletes in endurance sports and CrossFit.
This article is based on a video on our YouTube channel. Check it out here and make sure to subscribe!
The conversation kicked off by referencing Wim Hof, a pioneer in the field of extreme cold exposure and breathing techniques. Hof has become famous for his ability to endure ice baths and physically uncomfortable conditions, showing how mental focus and body conditioning can help people tolerate pain. Hof's method is an example of overriding the body’s typical responses to cold and discomfort through controlled breathing and mental preparation.
This concept isn’t far removed from what athletes in CrossFit and endurance sports experience. As Hiller and Ruth pointed out, these athletes build their capacity to endure pain over time. They dive deep into what is commonly referred to as "the pain cave," training themselves to push through levels of pain that would be unbearable for the average person.
In endurance sports like marathons or Ironman competitions, the body typically sends out a couple of strong fatigue signals: localized muscle pain and overall metabolic exhaustion (e.g., a high heart rate or overheating). Endurance athletes can train themselves to recognize and even ignore some of these signals to a degree. For instance, it's common to see athletes collapse just after crossing the finish line, their bodies essentially shutting down once the task is complete.
Ruth highlighted that endurance athletes only deal with a few major fatigue signals, which may make it easier for them to override these mechanisms. By managing their energy, hydration, and fueling strategies, they can push their bodies to impressive levels of endurance. However, as in the case of the original marathon runner, pushing too far can lead to serious consequences like complete physical breakdown.
In contrast, CrossFit presents a much more complex environment when it comes to managing and bypassing fatigue. Athletes in CrossFit face a "shotgun" of fatigue signals due to the nature of the sport. Not only do they have to endure cardiovascular exhaustion, but they also must maintain proper bracing and technique while lifting heavy weights, often in quick succession. For example, a workout might include rowing, running, and then immediately transitioning to heavy barbell lunges—all while their bodies are producing excess CO2 and their heart rates are skyrocketing.
As Ruth explains, there’s simply more going on in CrossFit workouts compared to endurance events. The body has to monitor a range of signals, from spinal bracing to metabolic fatigue, which makes it harder for an athlete to mentally override the body’s natural safety mechanisms. In CrossFit, the risk of injury becomes greater because athletes are pushing their limits not only in terms of endurance but also in terms of strength, coordination, and balance.
Despite advancements in mental training and conditioning, both Hiller and Ruth agree that there’s a limit to how much athletes can override their body’s safety mechanisms—especially in CrossFit. While endurance athletes can sometimes push through intense fatigue, CrossFit demands more from the body, making it harder to ignore all the warning signs. Even with the best training, there comes a point where the body simply won’t allow an athlete to continue. Muscles fail, coordination breaks down, and the body’s natural "circuit breakers" kick in to prevent catastrophic injury.
An interesting parallel drawn during the discussion was the extreme stories of people who bypass safety mechanisms in life-or-death situations. For example, there are cases of individuals lifting cars to save someone’s life, fueled by an adrenaline rush and the brain’s decision to prioritize survival over self-preservation. However, the speakers agreed that this extreme form of bypassing safety mechanisms doesn’t apply to sports like CrossFit. The stakes in competitive events are simply not high enough for athletes to tap into that level of mental and physical override.
The conversation highlighted how athletes in endurance sports and CrossFit face different challenges when it comes to pushing through pain. In endurance sports, the signals are simpler, allowing athletes to train their minds and bodies to endure through long periods of discomfort. But in CrossFit, the variety and intensity of fatigue signals create a much more complicated scenario. Athletes have to manage everything from strength to cardiovascular fitness, making it almost impossible to override all of the body’s safety mechanisms at once.
This distinction is crucial for anyone looking to understand what it takes to excel in these sports. While endurance athletes may train to block out pain and exhaustion, CrossFit athletes must work within the limits of what their bodies can handle. The complexity of CrossFit means there’s more at stake, from muscle failure to potential injury, and no amount of mental toughness can fully compensate for the physical demands of the sport.
While it’s fascinating to think about pushing past physical limits, the conversation between Hiller and Ruth makes one thing clear: the body’s safety mechanisms are there for a reason. Whether in endurance sports or CrossFit, athletes can train themselves to tolerate more pain and fatigue, but only to a certain point. The complexity of the fatigue signals in CrossFit, combined with the intensity of the workouts, means that athletes need to be especially mindful of their bodies' limits.
In the end, both endurance and CrossFit athletes can benefit from understanding the balance between pushing hard and respecting the body’s natural safety systems. While mental toughness is key, knowing when to stop might just be the most important skill of all.
If you enjoyed this discussion, make sure to head over to our YouTube channel and subscribe!